| Product specification | Confirm net type, mesh size, net depth and length, twine diameter, color, selvedge, and any requested hanging or finishing details. Make sure units and measurement methods are stated. | A dated specification sheet, dimensioned drawing, and a sample made to the same specification as the quotation. | Vague descriptions such as “standard size,” or quotations that omit key dimensions and tolerances. | 25% |
| Material and twine consistency | Check the stated polymer, monofilament diameter, color consistency, and whether the material is virgin or recycled if that matters to the application. Compare samples with the written specification. | Material declaration, lot identification, sample measurements, and an agreed method for checking diameter and appearance. | Unexplained material substitutions, inconsistent color, or no method for identifying production lots. | 15% |
| Strength and intended performance | Evaluate mesh or net strength against the intended fishing conditions and applicable buyer requirements. Clarify whether results refer to yarn, a mesh, or a finished net, since these are different test items. | Test reports stating the specimen, test method, conditioning, result, and sample or lot reference. Agree on acceptance limits before ordering. | Strength claims without test details, or results that cannot be connected to a sample or production lot. | 15% |
| Quality control and workmanship | Review checks for mesh dimensions, knots or joints, broken or uneven strands, net shape, finishing, and packing. Ask how defects are recorded and how nonconforming goods are handled. | Inspection checklist, sample inspection records, defect limits, and a pre-shipment inspection plan agreed by both parties. | No documented inspection process, unclear defect criteria, or refusal to agree on a remedy for nonconforming goods. | 12% |
| Compliance and product documentation | Identify the destination-market requirements that apply to the product and shipment. Confirm that any requested declarations, test reports, or certificates cover the actual product and intended use. | Relevant, current documents with scope, issuer, product description, and validity details. Verify documents with the issuing organization where appropriate. | Generic certificates that do not identify the product, expired documents, or claims of universal compliance without supporting evidence. | 8% |
| Production capability and capacity | Check whether the supplier can produce the requested net construction and volume, maintain repeatability, and manage peak-season orders. Distinguish actual production capability from outsourced processes. | A production-process overview, realistic capacity and lead-time estimates, and a clear explanation of any subcontracted steps. | Unverified capacity promises, unexplained changes in lead time, or undisclosed subcontracting that affects quality or delivery. | 8% |
| Lead time and delivery reliability | Confirm production time, sample time, shipping arrangements, packaging, and the point at which the delivery clock starts. Allow for transport and customs time when planning arrival. | A written production schedule, shipment milestones, packing details, and a process for communicating delays. | A single delivery date with no production assumptions, or no responsibility assigned for shipment documentation and packing details. | 7% |
| Quotation and commercial clarity | Compare like-for-like quotations, including specification, quantity, packaging, tooling or setup charges, payment terms, quotation validity, and delivery terms. | An itemized quotation linked to the approved specification, with currency, quantity basis, and delivery terms clearly stated. | A notably low price with missing specification details, unclear extra charges, or terms that change between quotation and order. | 5% |
| Communication and issue resolution | Assess how accurately the supplier answers technical questions, confirms changes, and responds to quality or delivery issues. Keep specifications and approvals in writing. | Written answers to technical questions, order-confirmation records, and an identified contact for production and after-sales issues. | Repeatedly changing answers, unconfirmed revisions, or no clear process for handling complaints. | 5% |