| Applicable codes and product approvals | 20% | Confirm the proposed pump package is suitable for the project’s adopted codes, authority requirements, and specified approval status. | Applicable code and edition identified; documentation for any required listing or approval verified against the exact model and configuration. UL listing or FM approval should be confirmed where the project requires it. | _____ |
| Hydraulic selection and system fit | 15% | Check that the selected pump meets the required flow and pressure conditions and is appropriate for the system’s water supply and operating requirements. | Selection curve and duty point supplied; required flow, pressure, suction conditions, driver capacity, and operating range reviewed by the project’s qualified fire-protection professionals. | _____ |
| Package configuration | 10% | Review the proposed pump, driver, controller, base, accessories, and interfaces as a coordinated package. | Itemized scope identifies included equipment, electrical and piping interfaces, control requirements, accessories, and any exclusions or by-others work. | _____ |
| Quality assurance and traceability | 10% | Assess how the supplier controls manufacturing quality and identifies the equipment delivered for the project. | Documented inspection and quality processes; equipment identification and serial-number traceability; clear process for recording and resolving nonconformities. | _____ |
| Factory testing and acceptance support | 10% | Establish what tests are included, how results are recorded, and whether witness or acceptance testing can be supported. | Written test scope and reporting format; agreed test parameters; arrangements for any specified witness testing and site acceptance testing. | _____ |
| Technical documentation | 10% | Determine whether the supplier will provide the information needed for review, installation, operation, inspection, and maintenance. | Submittal data, certified drawings where specified, pump curves, wiring information, installation instructions, operating manuals, and maintenance schedules. | _____ |
| Delivery and project coordination | 5% | Evaluate whether the proposed schedule and communication process align with the project’s procurement and installation milestones. | Written lead-time estimate, delivery assumptions, milestone plan, shipping responsibilities, and a named point of contact for schedule updates. | _____ |
| Installation and commissioning assistance | 8% | Clarify the level of technical support available during installation, startup, and commissioning. | Defined scope, availability, and fees for field assistance; startup checklist; clear division of responsibilities among supplier, installer, and project team. | _____ |
| Parts, service, and ongoing support | 7% | Check how service requests and replacement-parts needs will be handled over the expected operating life of the equipment. | Parts identification process, service contact route, stated support coverage, warranty terms, and any response-time commitments documented in writing. | _____ |
| Commercial clarity | 5% | Compare proposals on a consistent scope and identify cost, warranty, and contractual assumptions. | Itemized quotation; stated exclusions, freight, taxes, payment terms, warranty coverage, and pricing for optional services or accessories. | _____ |
| Total | 100% | Suggested weighted result: add each criterion’s weight × score ÷ 5. Use the same scoring method and project requirements for every proposal. | _____ / 100 |