| 1 | Project Application | Confirm whether the panel is intended for an exterior wall, roof, cold room, cleanroom, partition, or agricultural building. Define indoor temperature, humidity, wind exposure, snow load, span, and support spacing before comparison. | A completed technical questionnaire, design drawings, load requirements, installation orientation, and site exposure information. | Check that the proposed panel type and thickness match the project drawings and structural calculations. | 10% | __/10 |
| 2 | Core Material | Common nominal thermal-conductivity ranges are approximately 0.022–0.026 W/m·K for PIR, 0.024–0.030 W/m·K for PUR, 0.032–0.038 W/m·K for EPS, and 0.035–0.040 W/m·K for mineral wool. Actual declared values must be used for design. | Core type, density, declared thermal conductivity, thickness options, moisture resistance, adhesive type, and production lot information. | Review the technical data sheet and laboratory test reports. Do not compare suppliers using core density alone. | 15% | __/15 |
| 3 | Panel Thickness and Thermal Performance | Typical insulated panel thicknesses include 50, 75, 100, 120, 150, and 200 mm. A preliminary wall U-value target is often about 0.20–0.30 W/m²·K, but the correct value depends on the local energy code and building use. | Declared U-value or R-value, calculation method, joint thermal-bridge details, dimensional tolerance, and thickness availability. | Compare declared performance at the same thickness and temperature conditions; confirm the calculation includes panel joints where required. | 15% | __/15 |
| 4 | Steel Face Thickness and Strength | Color-coated steel facings commonly fall within approximately 0.40–0.60 mm nominal thickness. A specified minimum yield strength of around 280 MPa or higher is frequently used, subject to the structural design and profile. | Base-metal thickness, nominal and minimum thickness, yield strength, tensile strength, profile geometry, flatness, and dimensional tolerances. | Request mill certificates or batch test reports and measure sample thickness with a calibrated gauge. | 12% | __/12 |
| 5 | Metallic Coating and Paint System | Metallic coating mass may commonly range from approximately 100–275 g/m², depending on exposure and specification. Exterior topcoat thickness is often about 20–35 μm, while the reverse coating is usually thinner. | Coating type, coating mass, primer and topcoat thickness, color reference, gloss level, UV rating, salt-spray performance, and cut-edge protection. | Check the coating declaration, paint-system data sheet, sample appearance, and independent coating-thickness measurements. | 12% | __/12 |
| 6 | Fire Performance | Fire performance is assembly-specific. Require a classification or test report appropriate to the core, facing, joints, thickness, and intended use. European projects commonly reference EN 13501-1 and EN 14509; other regions may use local reaction-to-fire or fire-resistance standards. | Reaction-to-fire classification, fire-resistance rating where applicable, test configuration, joint design, report number, and validity scope. | Confirm that the tested construction is identical or technically applicable to the proposed panel and installation method. | 15% | __/15 |
| 7 | Structural Load Capacity | Load capacity depends on thickness, span, profile, support spacing, facing strength, wind pressure, snow load, temperature, and allowable deflection. A generic load value should not be used without a supplier span table or engineering calculation. | Verified span tables, positive and negative load capacities, deflection limits, fastener requirements, and design assumptions. | Have the proposed panel checked against the project loads by a qualified structural professional. | 10% | __/10 |
| 8 | Joint, Water, and Air Tightness | The joint profile should provide continuous weather protection and thermal continuity. Roof panels require suitable end laps, sealants, closures, drainage details, and fastener layouts for the local climate. | Joint drawings, gasket or sealant specification, water-tightness test results, air-permeability data where relevant, and installation details. | Inspect a full-size joint sample and verify the installation manual covers corners, penetrations, openings, and roof transitions. | 8% | __/8 |
| 9 | Manufacturing Quality and Compliance | Prefer documented production controls, batch traceability, dimensional inspection, adhesive-quality checks, and corrective-action records. EN 14509 may be relevant for factory-made structural insulated panels in applicable markets. | Quality-management certificates, factory inspection records, product conformity documents, batch labels, and nonconformance procedures. | Review current certificates and request a pre-shipment inspection or independent factory audit for large orders. | 8% | __/8 |
| 10 | Delivery, Packaging, and Technical Support | Compare total delivered cost and schedule rather than unit price alone. Panels should be protected from moisture, impact, contamination, and prolonged direct sunlight during storage and transport. | Production lead time, minimum order quantity, packaging method, loading plan, delivery terms, replacement policy, installation support, and spare-accessory availability. | Request a written quotation with all accessories, freight, taxes, unloading assumptions, and delivery milestones clearly separated. | 5% | __/5 |
| Total Weighted Score | 100% | __/100 |